Thoughtless Writing Comments are Old School
March 3rd, 2011School are wonderful places… and for writers, too often the scene of crimes against creativity. I don’t know how many people I’ve seen in my coaching practice who have been unable to write or to enjoy it when they do because of something that happened to them in school. (And yes, schools also are places that can inspire writers as well).
Usually it goes along these lines: An enthusiastic writer turns something in to the teacher, whether a creative piece or an essay on the History of Western Civilization. The teacher, probably tired and cranky after a long day, is sitting at home grading papers when her own teen storms out the door to smoke cigarettes. Angrily, the teacher picks up the paper… and vents. She doesn’t just grade it, she adds a comment like “Whatever you do, make sure you don’t take up writing as a profession,” or “I’ve seen chimpanzees write better papers than this.”
Not helpful.
The student reads the paper, takes the comment personally, and that’s it. They have just enough doubt in their own ability (who doesn’t in school?) to believe the comment. Then they continue through the years finding “evidence” to back up the belief that they can’t write, which is just how the mind does things. We like to prove ourselves right, even if it’s painful and untrue.
Then, they show up at my door X number of years later because, despite that blow, an inner writing voice has been quietly trying to get their attention. And it’s been knocking at the door a long, long time.
Another version of this is the budding writer who turns in something highly creative… and it’s strangulated by grammar rules. So they start learning to jump through grammar hoops rather than creative hoola hoops.
Then there’s the academic who has gone on for advanced degrees and was taught a rigorous, stylized method of writing. Rather than learning to open and write from their passion, they make each word work. Hard. Each sentence has to stand at fancy angles to look smart, and be obtuse enough to impress. Their inner editor rides them with a whip the whole way.
Usually it doesn’t take long much coaching for a client to get beyond these wounds and start writing in a way that feels more natural and fun. But if you’re looking for a few tricks to try on your own, try:
- Take the thought, such as “Mrs. Blarneybum said my writing was worse than chicken scratch,” and imagine what her life might have been like. Instead of seeing her as the all knowing God she obviously wasn’t, humanize her. Imagine her getting home after a long day. Taking off her shoes and massaging her bunions. Eating cold Chinese food leftovers. And then sitting in her threadbare recliner to grade papers… and not seeing past her own pain or arrogance as she graded your writing. Just as you couldn’t see your writing objectively, neither could she.
- Don’t see writing as black or white, good or bad, acceptable or not. See it as shades of gray, and then get a paint brush, a dollop of yellow and red, and jump in and play. Do some word cartwheels. Don’t let your editor in, just have fun and don’t judge. Isn’t that why you want to write anyway, to perhaps get a message out WHILE you’re frolicking?
- Keep in mind that if you can talk, you can write. Period.
As adults, away from the grades and criticism, it’s our time to dip into the joyful, creative part of the writing process. If you’ve been waiting to write, don’t wait any longer – take the leap and see if you don’t just fly…
As founder of Backyard Pearls, LLC, Carolyn Scarborough helps people tap into their inner wisdom, then share it with the world through books, blogs and articles. As a Writing Wisdom Coach, she supports you through the journey from inspiring idea to published piece in a way that’s joyful, effortless and profitable.
She’s done almost every kind of writing imaginable, including magazine features, newspaper columns, books, journaling — even ghostwriting for Donald Trump! Her favorite sort of writing is the kind where she has to be really present to find the story, so her life and writing are both a constant awakening to a deeper, richer way to live in the world.
To subscribe to Backyard Pearls Newsletter, visit the site here.
Request your complimentary “Getting to Know You” session to start turning your inner whisperings into a published book, blog or article.
You may reprint the featured article, in its entirety, by including a byline and the following information: “Carolyn Scarborough, The Book Whisperer, helps people tap into their inner wisdom, then share it with the world through books, blogs and articles. You can get a free audio on overcoming writers block by clicking HERE.”